Did a Man From India Really Invent the Airplane Before the Wright Brothers?

The Junior Education Minister of India believes so.


Who invented the airplane?

Many would answer Orville Wright and Wilbur Wright, collectively known as the Wright brothers, because that is what’s written in science textbooks. But if you ask Satyapal Singh, the Junior Education Minister of India, he would answer a different name.

He believes that an Indian scholar by the name Shivkar Bapuji Talpade was the first to create a flying machine. Singh openly made this assertion in an address given to engineering graduates in New Delhi, saying that the airplane is among the ancient Indian ‘discoveries.’

“Why are students not taught that before the Wright brothers, an Indian called Shivkar Bapuji Talpade was the first to invent the airplane? This person invented the plane eight years before the Wright brothers. Are our students taught these things in IITs or not? They should be,” the minister insisted.

Singh referred to the ‘Pushpak Vimaan,’ a flying chariot that is described in the epic Ramayana as the vehicle in which Ravana kidnapped Lord Ram’s wife Sita, triggering the great war, as the inspiration of Talpade in making the first airplane.


Shivkar Bapuji Talpade, believed to be the first man to invent the airplane. Photo by Open Magazine

But the claims of Singh, as well as other Indians in online forums, are so far unverified and merely soaked with faux nationalism.

It does not help that there are literatures like a Bollywood film on this subject called Hawaizaada, which further leads people in India to believe that the attempted flight was successful in 1895.

Read more  Research: Renewable Power Still Needs Natural Gas as Backup

 Photo by Enrico Baccarini

Other versions of the story say that Talpade, when he was an instructor at the Sir J.J. School of Art, held the first airplane demonstration at Bombay’s Chowpatty beach, and that Talpade made the machine to fly nearly 1,500 feet above the ground for several minutes. The first airplane – for Singh, at least – was claimed to run on mercury or some type of urine, but no one is sure about that.

What is sure though is that Talpade has tried to fly an airplane, albeit unsuccessful. There are documents to support that including the life of Talpade and his works. But to say that he is the first to invent the airplane instead of the Wright brothers, that needs more than just an assertion but concrete evidence. Singh has to provide that before he rewrites history.

Sources: NDTV | The Huffington Post | The Wire

 

 

 

Dion Greg Reyes
A young civil engineer finding his place in the industry. Pilipino.

Comments 2

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. The Wright brothers were two fraudsters. They flew for the first time in 1908, not before. Their 1903-1905 flights, more than 150!! are just their fiction. Aviation appeared in 1906 and has nothing to do with the Wrights.
    See:
    wright1903dec17.altervista.org

  2. Others built flying machines before the right brothers, and a a few even rose into the air. What the Wright brothers accomplished was the first sustained, controlled flight of a heavier-than-air machine. It was their system of control, based on their 1902 glider, that they patented.

Did a Man From India Really Invent the Airplane Before the Wright Brothers?

Send this to a friend